Most business owners I talk to believe the path to more local customers runs through backlinks (links to your website from other websites). So they pay someone to collect them, month after month, and wonder why the phone stays quiet. In local SEO (search engine optimization, meaning everything that helps Google show your business to people nearby), the asset that matters most is the free listing you probably set up once and forgot about: your Google Business Profile.
That is the box with your map pin, hours, photos and reviews. And the way most owners "improve" it is quietly hurting them. Below are four myths I see over and over, what Google's own rules say instead, and what I would do in your place.
Why Your Google Business Profile Outworks Any Backlink in Local SEO
Every year, Whitespark runs the Local Search Ranking Factors survey, where local search specialists rate what actually moves rankings. In the 2026 edition, for the map results (the three businesses Google shows with a map, often called the map pack), the numbers look like this:
Your reviews live on your profile too. Put those two together and the profile accounts for about half of what decides who shows up on the map. Links, at 8%, are a small slice by comparison.
To be fair to links: in the regular results below the map, they still carry real weight (about 24% in the same survey). I am not telling you links are worthless. I wrote about the kind of links that do help local businesses a few weeks ago. But if you want the phone to ring from Google Maps, the profile is where the payoff is.
One more change worth knowing. Google has been retiring the old questions and answers section on profiles since late 2025, and in the US it is being replaced by Ask Maps, an AI assistant that answers customers' questions by reading your profile, your reviews and your website. Your profile is no longer just a listing. It is the source material Google uses to talk about you.
So the profile matters. The problem is what people do to it.
Myth 1: A Bigger Service Area Gets You Found in More Towns
This is the most common one. You serve a metro area, so you add every town you can think of, up to Google's limit of 20 service areas. More towns listed, more towns where you show up. Right?
No. When Sterling Sky, a respected local SEO agency, tested this directly, the service area had no effect on rankings. Rankings were tied to the physical address used to verify the business. The service area only changes what customers see: the shaded region on the map showing where you travel.
Google also says your overall area should not reach more than about 2 hours of driving from where you are based. Stretch past that and you invite two problems:
Should you still fill in your service areas? Yes, honestly, with the towns you really work in. I explained why your address decides so much of your reach in an earlier post. Just do not expect a long list of towns to do the ranking work for you.
Myths 2 and 3: The Virtual Office and the Extra Listing
When owners figure out that the address drives rankings, the next idea is usually a shortcut. Rent a cheap virtual office or a coworking desk in the town you want to win, and create a second profile there. Or skip the office and simply make one listing per town.
Both break Google's rules, and Google is unusually clear about them:
Here is what that looks like in practice.
| The myth | What Google actually says | What it can cost you | What I recommend |
|---|---|---|---|
| "List every town and you will show up in all of them" | Up to 20 areas, about 2 hours' drive, and the list does not move your ranking | Calls from places you cannot serve | List only the towns you really work in |
| "A virtual office gets you into a new city" | Not eligible unless it is staffed, signed and open to customers | Suspension of that listing | Use your real address, or open a real location |
| "One listing per town covers more ground" | One profile per service-area business | Extra listings removed, and your main profile can be dragged into review | One profile, plus a page per town on your website |
| "Frequent edits keep the profile active" | Name changes might need re-verification; a new address must be verified again | Edits stuck in review, sometimes for days | Change core details rarely; add photos and reply to reviews often |
Myth 4: Editing Your Profile Every Week Keeps It "Active"
Somewhere along the way, owners picked up the idea that Google rewards constant changes. So they tweak the business name, swap categories, adjust the description, and do it again a few weeks later.
There is a real idea buried in there. Google does favor profiles that look alive, and I covered why a profile that looks abandoned slips on the map a few weeks ago. But "alive" means new reviews, your replies to them, fresh photos and posts. It does not mean rewriting your core details.
Google's own help pages are plain about the risk:
While that review or re-verification is happening, your fixes sit in a queue and you are not in control of the timeline. My rule of thumb: touch the name, address and main category only when something in the real world has changed. Photos, review replies and posts? Add those as often as you like.
What an Indianapolis Cleaning Company Should Do Instead
Let me show you how all four myths stack up in one business. Picture a house cleaning company in Indianapolis, Indiana. Six cleaners, one office on the south side, a good reputation, and a phone that rings far less than it should.
The owner has done everything the internet told her to do. Her profile lists 20 service areas, all the way out to Fort Wayne, more than two hours away. She rented a coworking desk in Carmel and made a second listing there, because Carmel households are her best customers. And she has changed her business name three times in a year, adding "House Cleaning Indianapolis" to the end each time she reads a new tip.
Here is the plan I would hand her, roughly in this order:
None of this is glamorous. It takes a few hours to set up, then about 15 minutes a week for reviews and photos. In a case like this, I would expect the change to show up within 6 to 10 weeks: fewer calls from towns she cannot serve, more calls from the suburbs she wants, and no suspension hanging over her head.
Curious what working on something like this together looks like? My process page walks through each step, and the FAQ answers the questions most owners ask first.
The Bottom Line
Backlinks are not your best local SEO asset. Your Google Business Profile is, and the fastest way to waste it is to stretch it, duplicate it or keep rewriting it. Keep it honest, keep it alive with reviews and photos, and put the rest of your effort into your website.
If you want a second pair of eyes on your profile, get in touch and I will tell you exactly what I would change.
